Zoey and Santana arrive at the office of a catering service ran by Anastasia. The girls want a refund because they were very unhappy with the service. Anastasia tells them she is sorry, but no refunds. Well, the girls tell Anastasia that there are no hard feelings and want to hire her services again, so they give her an address to meet them for a look over of a new location. When Anastasia arrives, the girls ambush her with pies. She is pied hard and they strip her down to her panties in the process. They want to teach her a lesson, so they leave her locked in the abandon warehouse for a few days. Zoey returns to check in on her and to continue the taunting. When Zoey is about to leave, she is grabbed by Anastasia and has her dress ripped off and is pied. Zoey left the key to the warehouse in her car and can`t get out because the door locks from the outside. Well, the girls keep going at it with more pies, until they are exhausted. Three days pass and Santana enter the room and finds both girls on the floor and still smearing cream on each other. Santana tells them they are both stupid for being locked in the wearhouse, but then realizes she forgot the key as well. So now Zoey and Anastasia pie helpless Santana and this starts a messy threesome pie fight. The landlord enters the room and finds it a mess and is upset, so he yells at the girls and throws the last of the pies at them.