Tilly is a contestant for the game show Cash or Mess. She is a school teacher from Minnesota and thinks the game is going to be G rated family fun, but it turns out to be the opposite as she is dressed in a sling shot bikini. Zoey is the host and tells Tilly she needs to draw from a hate to win cash or have messy things poured over her. Well, Tilly is hesitant, but needs to win money, so she takes the challenge. Poor Tilly is subjected to all kinds of savory pours over the head, but also is winning cash in the process. The game becomes even more humiliating for Tilly as she has her bikini pulled off during the game. Tilly must do the slop challenge to win 10 grand. All she need to do it find a ball with her mouth from a bucket of slop mix. Tilly dunks her head in the slop bucket numerous time until she finds the ball for the big win.