Penelope is a returning contestant for `Figure it Out` and must guess what fetish her home contestant is into by asking yes and no questions. For every wrong guess, she will be pied or slimed. Needless to say, she guesses wrong and gets the full pie and slime treatment. When she is done, she asks for the cameras to be turned off so she can get out of her outfit. Unfortunately the cameras are still rolling and the audience lets her know how enjoyable it is to watch her strip down to only her white socks. She is then slimed for good measure.