Michelle is the next contestant of Name That Pie. Host Penelope explains to Michelle that she must guess the name of the pie she is holding. If she gives the correct answer, she will win cash, but with the wrong answer, she must remove an article of clothing and be pied in the face. Needless to say, Michelle is not very good at guessing the names of pies. She ends up nude and totally covered in pie slop. She does win a concilation prize, a membership to the pie of the month club. She receives her gift on stage with pies being smashed in her face.